Warmoth has already gotten me a return label. I think the ding is just in the finish; they said they can refinish.
And now I've got more time to figure out how to build it out. I've got the pickups, JB Jr bridge, Duckbucker middle, and Little 59 neck. I've got them installed in my test Strat, trying them out. Not sure how I want to wire them up yet, regular blade switch, or I've got a Freeway kicking around.