here is my two sense:
Alot has changed since the 50's and 60's.
We now have alot more options as guitar players.
Some people like driving around in a 57' Chevy with no air conditioning.
Some people like driving around in a 2009 Mercedes Benz with all the electronics and gadgets.
My opinion:
Most of the old vintage stuff sounds exactly that, old and vintage.
The lower fidelity and the way it colors your sound is what people like about it.
I prefer the rack mount gear and the higher fidelity and versatility.
My school of thought is you can always filter out some highs and tweak it to make it warmer but you can't add highs and definition to a rig that never had it.
And with the right guy setting up the rack to emulate the vintage stuff you can't tell in a blind test, ESPECIALLY live or in the mix with a whole band.
Alot has changed since the 50's and 60's.
We now have alot more options as guitar players.
Some people like driving around in a 57' Chevy with no air conditioning.
Some people like driving around in a 2009 Mercedes Benz with all the electronics and gadgets.
My opinion:
Most of the old vintage stuff sounds exactly that, old and vintage.
The lower fidelity and the way it colors your sound is what people like about it.
I prefer the rack mount gear and the higher fidelity and versatility.
My school of thought is you can always filter out some highs and tweak it to make it warmer but you can't add highs and definition to a rig that never had it.
And with the right guy setting up the rack to emulate the vintage stuff you can't tell in a blind test, ESPECIALLY live or in the mix with a whole band.