I did use a brad point. I think my issue was trying to exactly match the size, which was very hard to be exactly drilling the center. If anyone has a fool proof way, I'm open to it. Warmoth uses dot markers which are some sort of clay. If they were plastic, you can drill out the center then retrieve the rest pretty easily. Warmoth markers are there to stay. I still have options to experiment on that neck and will keep trying.
The finish on the pick guard is Rubio. I used a white pre stain then white Rubio 2C, so it's complete. I also put a ceramic coat on it, which I have found does a fantastic job eliminating pick scratch marks. My last Pale Moon Ebony build still has zero scratches with months of playing time.