I spent some time with the DAW and the soldering iron today, and I have some things to share! Initially I wired this guitar with these options on the 5-Way:
Bridge (Full)
Bridge (Split)
Bridge (Split) + Neck (Split)
Neck (Split)
Neck (Full)
Today I recorded samples, both clean and crunchy, of all of those, then I opened her up and re-wired so that the middle position was Bridge (Full) +Neck (Full), both pickups full instead of split. I recorded samples of that option as well. The recordings were made with Line 6 Helix into Logic Pro X. The strings were not removed when I re-wired it, so they are the same. I did swap that Pure Tone jack out for a Switchcraft, but I'm going to go waaaaaaay out on a limb and say there was no appreciable sonic impact....
Once I had the recordings done I listened to them all over and over, back-to-back-to-back-to-back, and picked the 5 out of those 6 options that I wanted to keep...
It's 12 separate clips, so I figured it would be easier and less cumbersome to post them as a Soundcloud compilation rather than individual links:
<edit: it's 16 now...>
[soundcloud]https://soundcloud.com/vb-tunes/sets/pickup-samples-candy-apple-red-thinline[/soundcloud]
Ultimately I decided to ditch the split bridge pickup in preference of having both combined pickup options, like so:
Bridge (Full)
Bridge (Split) + Neck (Split)
Bridge (Full) + Neck (Full)
Neck (Split)
Neck (Full)
I actually found the split bridge pickup to have some interesting character, both clean and dirty. I didn't consider it a throw-away at all. Had to choose though, and I'm quite happy with the current configuration.
What do y'all's think?