Leaderboard

Proof

Superlizard

Hero Member
Messages
2,514
With all this talk about best/worst and the spoof vids...

Here's proof that Jimmy Page is the world's best guitarst:

[youtube=425,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZMFG7A-O_A[/youtube]
 
Superlizard said:
With all this talk about best/worst and the spoof vids...

Here's proof that Jimmy Page is the world's best guitarst:

[youtube=425,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZMFG7A-O_A[/youtube]

Good God, that's almost difficult to sit through. You know, I'll openly say that I love Jimmy Page for what he did. He has written some of the most timeless riffs that have ever been put to tape. You can listen to a Led Zep CD today and it sounds as fresh as it did 30 years ago. God Bless him. But, man, when he's on stage he makes me cringe. One of the ugliest sounds I've ever heard and he is so sloppy. His live playing is so different from anything I've heard on tape that it almost makes me wonder if he was actually the one playing.
MULLY
 
it's a shreds video folks.  s'posed to be a spoof  

pretty funny imho :icon_jokercolor:
 
mayfly said:
it's a shreds video folks.  s'posed to be a spoof  

pretty funny imho :icon_jokercolor:

Sadly, no it's not a spoof. Here's the actual footage from the concert.
Start it at 2 minutes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkApNqfg7tE&feature=video_response#t=2m00s
 
CouchSpud said:
mayfly said:
it's a shreds video folks.  s'posed to be a spoof  

pretty funny imho :icon_jokercolor:

Sadly, no it's not a spoof. Here's the actual footage from the concert.
Start it at 2 minutes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkApNqfg7tE&feature=video_response#t=2m00s
That's because he's not playing a tele, like he SHOULD be.
 
CouchSpud said:
mayfly said:
it's a shreds video folks.  s'posed to be a spoof  

pretty funny imho :icon_jokercolor:

Sadly, no it's not a spoof. Here's the actual footage from the concert.
Start it at 2 minutes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkApNqfg7tE&feature=video_response#t=2m00s

I remember watching that live and was amazed at the amount of SUCK Jimmy was putting forward.  To me, Page is a GOD.  He had to have been hammered or
578.gif
 
Gosh Jimmy, oh Jimmy. You practically taught me guitar, but... I'm pretty sure you went CRAZY somewhere along the line. I am on the same page as dmraco, I love Page and I just can't watch that video. His live tone starting in the mid-70s was always bad, but this takes it to a whole new level.

However, 1969-early 70s tone was great I think
[youtube=425,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igNo4-mpP7g[/youtube]
 
I would bet we could find the worst moment for almost any guitarist. If jimmy is overrated I sure wish I was overrated!
 
Jimmy can fumble-finger all night long - hell he doesn't even have to show up to the concert - and yet he still rules...

...because he's Jimmy Page.  :icon_biggrin:  :party07:
 
I have nothing bad to say about Jimmy Page. besides, this was like some sort of one-off concert wasnt it?  :rock-on: Mr. Page!!!! :party07:

Brian
 
Stephen R said:
Jimmy Page ... an inspiration to all sloppy guitarists like myself  :headbang:

He was alway "sloppy" but that vid is just horrid.  Sounded like a kid trying to play zepplin in a music store while trying out his 1st guitar...

Still...jimmy is the master.  Any seen IT Might Get Loud yet??
 
If you ask me, he's almost a complete phoney. A lot of his songs / timeless riffs are shtolen. Most of Zeppelin's controversial court cases could've been avoided had they JUST GIVEN CREDIT.

Considering THAT, and the fact that he's praised (for some backwards reason) for being sloppy pretty much takes him off the pedestal.

I have felt cheated by LZ for years, once I determined for myself that the bulk of what made them great was pentatonic exploitation. I still very much appreciate John Bonham and John Paul Jones.

It's funny when people ask you "what's the best band in the world: Led Zeppelin or The Rolling Stones?"  :laughing8: They can both jump off already.



Would you steal from your best friend? How bout if your best friend was Jeff Beck?!
 
In 1988, Led Zeppelin had been disbanded for 8 years, since the death of drummer John Bonham. Page had basically been sitting in his castle shooting heroin for that time - he scored a movie and played a few gigs. In 1991, he formed Coverdale/Page, but he wasn't into it.

The interesting thing to me is judging playing from 30 years ago by today's standards. Could you write the stuff? I mean, you can take any bar band guitarist of today, transport him back to 1967, and he'd be a guitar superstar. Now - transport him back there, but without any of the licks he learned from Page, Hendrix, Van Halen, Clapton, Beck etc. If today's guitarists are so much better, where are the songs that have replaced Led Zeppelin on the radio, without being totally influenced by them? Without Zepp, there is no Aerosmith or Guns 'n Roses, that's for sure.

My Toyota is a far better car than a Model T Ford, too. Here's a clue - if you posted a video of yourself playing like that on YouTube, nobody would even care, because you don't matter in the world. Does it make you feel big, insulting Jimmy Page? Does it "prove" that you could've been a star, with a bit more luck? Clearly, being an adequate guitarist and living in London in 1965 was a potent opportunity to make history. But we weren't there.... There are tons of "classic rock" songs which pretty much suck, anything with Big Brother and the Holding Company for example. I'd rather listen to better music than Led Zeppelin, so I do - but I don't even expect to hear it on the radio. However, slagging Page is like saying Tom Brady could blow Knute Rockne off the football field, or that Gen. MacArthur was a greater general than Alexander the Great, who was just in the right place at the right time. Hint: almost everybody is in the wrong place at the right time, get used to it. :laughing3:
 
Jimmy is one of those guys that had a lot of bad nights, but when he was on, he was brilliant. I enjoy the few good concert moments I've seen, but for me the magic is in the recordings and in the sounds and the songs (even the rip offs which were obviously far more successful than the originals).

I don't know why LZ didn't always give credit where it was due. I know they were some serious money hungry bastards, and their business practices changed the way bands get paid - but yeah Jimmy should have given more to the people who's songs they covered. I guess they got away with it for a while because most of the blatant rip off stuff (besides the blues stuff that everyone covered a million times) was stuff hardly anyone had ever heard of.

I'm going to have to chalk it up to them being British. Thieving bastards ;)
 
Stupid Jack White... I wonder if they exaggerated his character for the movie or if he's really that weird. (apologies to any fans of his) Made me like Edge and Jimmy more, though Edge's overkill rig bugged me a little.
 
nathana said:
Gosh Jimmy, oh Jimmy. You practically taught me guitar, but... I'm pretty sure you went CRAZY somewhere along the line. I am on the same page as dmraco, I love Page and I just can't watch that video. His live tone starting in the mid-70s was always bad, but this takes it to a whole new level.

However, 1969-early 70s tone was great I think
[youtube=425,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igNo4-mpP7g[/youtube]
Jimmy's brain cells weren't depleted back in the 70's yet, that's the difference from then until '87... :tard:
 
Back
Top