You don't think a lawsuit is warranted, dbw?
Firstly, I am glad that Crappy can see beyond the bleeding obvious disappointment he must have felt, when he realised the situation he was in with Gibson, and be able to comment favourably about the sound the guitar has etc. That takes a lot of resolve to go ahead and I am quite impressed by that, I know I could not have done that, and probably sold off the guitar at the first possible opportunity. And I bet all he wants to do now is move on, and not go over and over with people about the volute.
But secondly, looking at the situation that he arrived at, it must be a hell of a shock in this day and age that a corporation with a high profile brand name would take the view they have and basically 'called him (and other owners) outside' for a fight by insisting nothing is wrong.
No matter where you live in the developed world there are loads of trade practices and consumer laws that generally protect buyers from inferior goods. Very surprised that not 1 of the 300 owners seemingly affected, felt it necessary to take the issue further. Mind you, I bet Gibson may have gained 300 sales without extensive warranty claims, but they've probably lost a good number of them for any future guitar sales with this attitude.