You probably got hand oil or other oils on one of the layers. In my experience, this will cause trouble. I had used mineral oil to level/wet sand the layers on my tele, and I didn't get it all off. I wiped it down with naphtha and follow the general guidelines, but when I started to polish it, it kinda peeled off. It was a very thin layer of lacquer, so it didn't come off in a sheet or anything, but when looking at it carefully under light you could definitely see it. Just a problem with not getting all of the oil off.
Patrick