stubhead said:
"Great" is always so subjective.... In a band context where a guitarist is supposed to be capable of playing musical sounding chords behind other band members, there have been some great-sounding guitarists and songs using amps like the Roland Jazz Chorus 120 or a Fender Twin Reverb turned down so low there's no overdrive to speak of. When I listen to Hendrix's "Cry of Love" or old Zeppelin or Stones or Beatles, it's astonishing how clean most of the guitar parts really are. A big reason the solos stand out is because they're the only overdriven things on there.... I have always maintained that you're not actually a musician if you have to have "your sound", and your sound only, to be able to play anything. If you can't play a guitar plugged into a dead-clean amp with no compressor, wah, or overdrive and make something musical happen with note choices alone, you need to stop the shred and slow down and learn something.
I personally feel Hendrix's last work was his best. The Songs on "Cry of Love" got mish-mashed together with "Rainbow Bridge" and some others to pad it out to a CD length, but if you listen to "Angel", "Night Bird Flying" and "Drifting", that's a dead-clean Twin Reverb there. When Steve Morse or Eric Johnson fingerpick an electric, there's no faked up piezo-pickup "acoustic" nonsense, it's just a serious musician who knows how to play a whole lot more than just screams. And, I also like to plug three fuzztones together.... :headbang1:
Jimi is my biggest influence, I love his music and think if he had not died would have lead us into a new arena of music, He was experimenting with so much at the end. Songs such as you mentioned are of his greatest work,and the clean tones are part of that. Like so many guitarist that we all love and rave about, Jimi was a rhythm guitarist first, and a soloist second. Eddy, Gary, and the list goes on of guitarist that we all love are as such, they may be able to wail but the clean sound they put down as backing tracks are what gets you into a song.
Effects are for soloist, a guitarist knows his instrument and has a vocabulary of chords that most only dream of.
I have 2 workshops I like to go to , one s a Jazz thing put n about 10 times a year by the teacher at the local college, it is for advanced players and we all get a workout that is the kind of stuff that keeps you interestedin playing new music.
the other is a jam session a couple of us host for guitarist that want to have a place to practice soloing techniques, we set up a groove on a loop and we each take a couple of runs at it developing ideas, the thing that gets me is how many guys wanting to learn to solo know very little more than E and A based Barre chords. When you ask them to play a major 7th they are stumped, much less a Add a 9th or a Diminshed chord.
The entire base of a song is the chordal development going on, yet so many guys want to forgo studying that and try to solo over chords they cannot play.
and when they get frustrated and start to make mistake,, out comes the distortion level, it goes up. I personally practice through a Epiphone Bass amp so I can CLEARLY hear everything, I feel f t does not sound good clean, it will never sound good dirty, it will just be loud.