well, as some of you guys know, i am pretty narrow minded about whats good in a guitar and what is total crap.
but IMO, it just doesnt have that fender strat vibe without the pickguard. so that means that if you are after the traditional, you need the pickguard, but if you want something more unique and modern, dont put on a pickguard.
i never liked the look or functionality of single coils being mounted directly to the wood.
it just has a "naked" unfinished look to it.
i always have the feeling that i need to be all delicate and careful when the pickup is exposed.. it just seems like i am golng to destroy the pickup at the solder joint or something because that thin pickup wire is exposed.
just my 2 cents.