TheOtherEric said:
Anyone who simply says “they’re amazing” isn’t telling the whole story. And anyone playing one right out of the box has a very poor quality neck despite what they claim.
"Amazing" covers a lotta ground and is somewhat subjective so I'd hold back on that adjective, but "very poor quality"? That's totally off-base. Warmoth's necks are
very high quality. If they weren't, they'd have gone out of business long ago. Some people DO play them right out of the box, and at that point they're still better than most OEM necks from the usual suspects.
But, they are "new parts" and are therefore somewhat unfinished in the interest of allowing the assembler/tech to adjust/customize to suit. The nut slots will be somewhat shallow - they don't know what kind or gauge strings you're going to use, or where you like your action set. The frets won't be leveled because they were just installed - Warmoth doesn't know how you like your frets crowned/dressed/polished/etc, so again, they leave that as a finishing activity for the assembler/tech to adjust/customize to suit. But, it's a freshly milled fretboard that's likely already slotted and freshly fretted, so they should be pretty damn close - just not within a gnat's kiss of level. The relief can't be set for the same reasons already mentioned. Gotta string 'er up and make 'er sweat a bit first.
But, a lot of that stuff is just nominal/normal work you'd do on any new guitar, and especially on any new parts. No manufacturer is prescient.
If you're not comfortable doing that kind of work, you can certainly still build the instrument anyway, see how you love it and what you'd like changed, then take it someone who is. No shame in that. Some of that finer work requires specialized tools and hard-won experience to accomplish well.
But, there are a lotta talented and experienced people on this board who are more than happy to share their knowledge to make it a fun and successful project for you. Any time you feel gray about something, you can always ask and somebody (probably a number of sombodies) will likely have already done it or know where there are resources to help. Everybody's made plenty of mistakes - it's how we learn. The only ones who don't make mistakes are those who aren't doing anything. So, have fun :laughing7: