Well, I got the guitar together this weekend. I'm not sure if it's the wood itself or the fact that the new body is chambered, but this guitar definitely livened up. It almost sounds contradictory, but the guitar seems to have a warmer bottom end with a brighter, snappier top end after the swap. I would say it sounds like a warmer version of a tele sound now. The coolest part is that the rail part of the pickups sounded pretty thin and weak before, but now they have a great Fendery vibe. Previously I would only use the P90 and humbucker sound but I think I'll be using the rail sounds more now. As for the weight, this body is almot too light! The neck wants to dive just a little. I may throw a little weight in the control cavity or I may just leave it alone - the jury's still out. Overall I think I have a more properly matched combination of parts now. Oh, and I stayed with the black pickguard. I tried it with just a mounting ring, but I had to keep the guard.
Thanks,
-Bobbie