Disco Scottie said:
Wow, that's 10 between the two of you. I guess it's a good choice!
it depends on what you prefer. I like a thin small neck, as it suits my playing better. Some like larger dimensions. I have an 1 11/16 neck & it feels wierd to play on, but it's all preference. Try them both out & see what feels better for you.
Btw, I just shaved down a wizard 1 5/8 neck to get it even sleeker. Unfortunately I like this waaaay too much & it has bee itching to do it to a few more.