Is this about the GAS you got for a solid color "butterscotch" tele? Maybe consider the light yellow they offer on the builder... -will that hit the spot? :dontknow:
I am imagining what you're looking for to sorta resemble the Fender road-worn tele, minus the road-wear. Maybe the light yellow would nail it... with the help of a single-ply matte black pickguard, of course.