Carved vs. Flat Top

[MoonageDaydream]

Which is better? I'm in the process of finding cash for my first build (LPS) and I don't know which is better.

Your Personal Preference and why etc. arty07:

 

[jackthehack]

Don't know that one is definitively better than the other; may depend on whether you are going for a more "old school" type of LPS build, like a '59 type with P90s, which would call for flat top, or a more custom modern type build that would incorporate a carved top.

 

[MoonageDaydream]

I might just do a flat top to save myself a hundred bucks...

 

[GoDrex]

I think some people might say that the added wood or the type of wood (like maple on mahogany) would have an effect on tone. Perhaps the added mass does have a small effect. I've heard some people say that maple on mahogany brightens the tone, but I've got an all mahogany LP and it seems plenty bright to me. Could be the pickups I got though. I like the look of the carved top a lot, but I understand trying to keep costs down.

 

[nathan a]

Looks alone, I love carved top double cuts

 

[shanejw]

I like having a carved top just because my forearm lays in a better spot than a flat top, makes for more comfortable playing I think.

 

[Orpheo]

I'd go for a carved top. it just looks more 'done' and its so much more prettier, imho. and yes, the added wood on a carved top guitar compared with a flat top gives it a different sound. most of the time it gives you a bit more growl and punch.

 

[MicahC]

Carved tops are prettier. And like Drex said, it's supposed to change the sound a little bit, but I couldn't tell much difference.

 

[spauldingrules]

I think Flat Tops are easier to play, though.  Just the way my right hand sits.  Maybe because I learned on an acoustic, which is flat.  Who knows - I just don't like playing carved tops.  You should go play both.  ALTHOUGH, when in doubt, get what's cheaper!

 

[lp1958]

I myself prefer carved tops.

I know some people think LPS's look a little strange but I quite like them.
I have a carved top LPS on order myself at the moment.

A maple top does make the inherent tone that little bit brighter.  But your pickup selection will have far greater effect.

If I were you I would go for what I could afford\like the look of best.

Best of luck.

 

[Kostas]

Carved top all the way :icon_thumright: