I'm an old fart, but these (Avenged) guys can really, really play. My guitar students turned me on to Avenged. Infinite speed doesn't do much for me if they're not saying much. First off, you have to be a good enough
writer and arranger - all of my fave guys either write their own stuff or drastically re-arrange things - doesn't matter if it's country, metal, whatever. (I make an exception for Bach & Beethoven :icon_biggrin
Music that got strongly "genrefied" like metal or blues tends to get tiresome - the best in these genres are clearly listening to a lot of music
outside of their own given turf. Jeff Loomis is really good, too.
I for one am glad that Portnoy left DT. That band had the weird distinction that the more members played on a given record, the worse it got. Petrucci's solo album is great, the Liquid Tension CD's a bit less so, and DT had more pretentiousness in their little fingers than a whole warehouse of David Bowie costumes... :guitaristgif: I'd like to hear what Petrucci & Myung could do with a power trio.