PhilHill said:
[text deleted because there's no need to quote a whole post, you're just wasting space]
And once again, sharp attack =/= bright.
I will refer you again to the fact
I literally have these guitars in this very room with me, giving a live, tangible reference point rather than romanticised folklore, and if you want to cite secondary opinions,
Warmoth themselves also say the same thing; rosewood bodies are extremely warm-toned.
edit:
Since it did strike me "hang on, I
do have a rosewood-bodied guitar right here" I figured I'd quickly record a couple of clips with it vs an alder-bodied but otherwise identical guitar that is also at hand.
You'll excuse the sloppy playing of a couple of basic chords but it's past 11pm and right now I'm supposed to be in bed happily drifting off on a fresh dose of painkillers which I am currently regretting not taking before I tried lifting that blasted guitar.
Two tracks, one on the bridge pickups and one on the neck. The first guitar in each is a solid alder Tele with a 25.5" one-piece maple neck. The second guitar is the solid rosewood Tele with a 25.125" two-piece maple neck.
The pickups in both guitars are the same across the board, Gibson Burstbucker #3 in both positions of both guitars, in all cases running to a 300k volume pot per pickup, no tone controls. (Obviously I can't guarantee each volume pot is 100% identical in value, but they were all CTS 300k pots advertised with a +/-5% tolerance.) Pickups are roughly the same height from the strings but I'm not going to check that precisely at this time of night. Both guitars have .0095 strings but I think they're different brands, d'addario on the rosewood and ernie ball on the alder
I think, not that that should make much difference.
Amp is only a Roland JC-22 because hey it's 11pm and anyway it makes for a usefully neutral playing field. EQ set with everything on 10.
https://soundcloud.com/aceflibble/sets/alder-v-rosewood-body
The difference on the bridge pickup is immediately noticeable; the rosewood body is far warmer (or some would say rounder, and others might say dull) in tone compared to the neutral balance of alder. (We are all agreed that alder is a neutrally-toned wood, yes?) For reference most of my Les Pauls with similar pickups have a bridge tone pretty much the same as this. (But I don't have a LP in this room today so that'll have to wait.)
The difference on the neck pickups is minimal, I expect because there's so much less treble to work with there anyway and the BB#3 is a fairly powerful pickup for the neck position and is probably 'overruling' the difference in construction. The rosewood still comes out warmer but it is admittedly a much smaller difference than with the bridge pickups.